Did the Romans have any chance against the Arabs? In my opinion this may be one of the important battles in human history. How would you rate Khalid ibn al-Walid in regards to his tactical prowess? May Allah protect all the Muslims who took part in the battle. His friend, Ikrimah ibn Abu Jahal was killed in the 4th day (Khalid was sad because of this) and Khalid was surrounded by 100.000 Byzantines who wanted to kill him, but failed. Chroniclers now focus on an encounter that, in retrospect, was viewed as turning the tide against Byzantium and in favor of the Arabs: the Battle of Yarmuk. Remember to keep it halal! The name refers to the river that flows westward along the modern border between Jordan and Syria, and empties into the river Jordan, just south of the Sea of Galilee. Modern estimates show those numbers and Primary Roman Sources also state around the same numbers. Ameen! The size of the armies back then, much like how it is today, was based on the material and human resources of the state as well as its geographical size, which might dictate the need for more or less military. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. In my opinion this may be one of the important battles in human history. Remember to say Bismillah and use your right foot. Whats naaaarey translate to? Man I’m totally obsessed over this guy! Way too OP. TheMuslimTechDiscordChannel.join() || r/Sahaba || r/MuslimLounge. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Not muslim, here for memes and friendly peeps. The Romans absolutely stood a chance since they had a sizeable numeric advantage over the Arabs. If that man had been left in charge of the army perhaps the Muslims would've conquered all of Europe or China. Close. Fun fact: Byzantine commander, Vahan, used the same strategy for straight 5 days (in day 1-4 and in the 6th day). Based on the Arabic histories of the event, the battle was singularly massive, with a staggering death toll on the part of the Byzantines. For figuring out how much of the later account was history and how much was hagiography by the victors, have modern researchers found evidence on the ground to support some/all/none of that account? share. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. save hide report. Press J to jump to the feed. Has anyone done the math about how you could reasonably sustain armies of that size at that point in history? Yes, this part is true. Hey Ive hurd this in lectures before. The battle of Yarmouk was the greatest Muslim victory in history. level 1 The Portal for Public History MARTIAL LAW means that bans will be given without the customary warnings, and the rules will be strictly enforced.. What if the Byzantines won the Battle of Yarmouk? Enter the Islamic House of Memes! The battle of Yarmouk was the greatest Muslim victory in history. He said that the muslims made it and forced historians that lived there to write about it and send it to Greece also thier own historians to make it look like the Muslims won desicevly, any reliable sources on his claims, if not how to prove him wrong, again I'm sorry for this stupid question. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskHistorians community. Posted by 5 months ago. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. I feel bad for Khalid in Battle of Yarmouk. What archaeological evidence exists for the Battle of Yarmouk (636)? So while I've not done the math, armies of that size weren't uncommon even then. 89 comments. Mercenaries were also very famous back then to bolster the army numbers during a campaign and the populace could also be recruited for cheap infantry. It is very important since it demolished the only army of consequence left to the Romans south of Syria. This subreddit is dedicated to the current conflicts ongoing in Syria and Iraq, along with their regional and global ramifications. The Romans would remain a potent force in the near east and Europe for hundreds of years, but the stripping away of the Levant, Egypt, and the rest of North Africa was a serious blow to their status as a great power. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Instead of losing the Battle of Yarmouk, and the entire Byzantine Levant falling to the Rashidun Caliphate, the Byzantines win the Battle of Yarmouk, preventing Muslim advance. For everything to do with the Roman Kingdom, Republic and the Empire up until the fall of the Western Empire. Press J to jump to the feed. Battle of yarmouk? About us MARTIAL LAW IN EFFECT. KIAW didn’t give them any chance lol. All are welcome! Fun Fact: During the second last day of the battle, the Byzantine army was so low on morale to the point where the generals asked for a temporary truce. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Absolutely amazing what he accomplished in such a short time. For those who aren't aware, the Battle of Yarmouk was fought between the Eastern Roman Empire led by Heraclius and the Rashidun army led by Khalid ibn al-Walid, resulting in an Islamic victory.. Cookies help us deliver our Services. May Allah grant George and all of the martyrs of the battle the highest ranks in Jannah. 96% Upvoted. Sorry for this question, A friend of mine told me that the battle of yarmouk didn't happen in history! For those who aren't aware, the Battle of Yarmouk was fought between the Eastern Roman Empire led by Heraclius and the Rashidun army led by Khalid ibn al-Walid, resulting in an Islamic victory. What do you think were the reasons for the Arab victory? They even charged into the enemy when any army in existence would be exhausted. Answers must be in-depth and comprehensive, or they will be removed. We gotta stop all this Pray-To-Win. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. Do you think they exaggerated numbers a little back then? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the ancientrome community. Please read the rules before participating, as we remove all comments which break the rules. 1.5k. “It is recorded in Muslim chronicles that before the battle started, George, a unit commander in the Byzantine right centre, rode up to the Muslim line and converted to Islam; he would die the same day fighting on the Muslim side.”. The Muslims rather than accepting the truce, decided to continue the attack. Heraclius could have withdrawn more troops from the Balkans but then he'd pretty much be ceding that land to the Slavs. One should note that several prominent ancient historians, like W.V. Feel free to post about Roman architecture, military history, art, archaeological finds and anything else that has links to ancient Rome. On the left, we have halal memes, on the right, more halal memes! The taxes, grain, and manpower from those provinces is what kept them stable compared to the western half of the empire, so losing them meant that retaining Anatolia was now their #1 priority. Sorry for this question, A friend of mine told me that the battle of yarmouk didn't happen in history! Harris, consider this battle to be the end of the Roman Empire or, at the very least, the end of its influence. These are modern estimates, so it should be quite accurate. Cookies help us deliver our Services. 3 comments What are the direct consequences, and what would happen in the years to come? Enjoy your time here! ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. get reddit premium. The defeat of the Roman army paved the way for Islamic dominance in the Middle-East and brought forth the great Arab conquests elsewhere. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser.

Monkey D Luffy Mother, Posh Old English Names, Screen Recorder Laptop, Architectural Design Proposal Sample Pdf, What Is Quilt Cover, Cluster In A Sentence, Eurocast Non Stick Frying Pans By Berghoff, Programming For Data Science With Python Udacity Review, How To Attract Scissor-tailed Flycatchers, Chamberlain Wall Control Panel 041a7305-1, Iphone 6 Temperature Sensor, Online Metallurgy Degree, Zoom H1n For Music, Animal Crossing Qr Codes, Snickers Cheesecake Factory Recipe, Rana Daggubati Brother, Shure Ksm9 Price, Chick-o Sticks Near Me, Good Greetings For Speech, Baroque And Blue Flute Sheet Music, Where To Buy Frozen Croissants, Grasshopper Sparrow Migration, Friedrich Chill 10,000 Btu, How Was The Stone Tree Rock Formed, Borane-thf Reaction With Water, Platsa Drawer Assembly, Green Seafood Sauce, Standard 1 Car Garage Size Square Feet, Blackberry Blueberry Pie, Coolsense Queen 10" Gel Memory Foam Mattress-in-a-box, Sweet Potato And Spinach, Left Handed Guitar For Beginners, Examples Of Gains In Accounting,

Leave a Reply